Home › Top-rated comic shops › Pennsylvania

Top-rated comic book stores in Pennsylvania

How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 121 of the 129 comic shops we list in Pennsylvania qualify; these are the top 10.

Ranked from public Google numbers. Not an endorsement.

1. 1

   Atomic City Comics

   4.6★★★★★ 1,075 reviews

   Philadelphia, PA · 638 South St
   Score 4,945 (4.6 × 1,075)

   Back issuesManga

   Comics are a huge deal in Philadelphia. I enjoy a good read from time to time. I am thankful that my City has a variety of venues that support this Comic Books. Maranatha ✝️ Shalom ✡️

2. 2

   Eide's Entertainment

   4.5★★★★★ 893 reviews

   Pittsburgh, PA · 1121 Penn Ave
   Score 4,019 (4.5 × 893)

   Back issuesVintage & keysFree Comic Book Day

   Three levels. Absolutely massive selection. The volume of product in the store is incredible. Huge oversized section of $1 loose unsorted comic books from the 80s and 90s on the main level. Lower level has a very complete and very extensive back issue collection. They seem to have absolutely everything.

3. 3

   Brave New Worlds

   4.7★★★★★ 704 reviews

   Willow Grove, PA · 433 W Moreland Rd
   Score 3,309 (4.7 × 704)

   Pull listsBack issuesMangaSignings

   I was looking everywhere for Gundam model kits and they didn’t have any but when I went to this store and saw the Gundams I was extremely happy and had a hard time choosing the gundams cause they all look so cool. This store deserves five stars I swear!

4. 4

   New Dimension Comics - Waterfront

   4.6★★★★★ 646 reviews

   Homestead, PA · 630 E Waterfront Dr
   Score 2,972 (4.6 × 646)

   Buys comics Back issues

   The ultimate N.E.R.D store!! (Never.Ending.Radical.Dude) I personally am not into comic books but once I found that they carry comic books based on some of my favorite cartoons I was intrigued. They had Zelda comic books, Naruto comic books, Dragon ball comic books.

5. 5

   Brave New Worlds

   4.7★★★★★ 576 reviews

   Philadelphia, PA · 55 N 2nd St
   Score 2,707 (4.7 × 576)

   Pull listsBack issuesMangaSignings

   Best comic store in Philly! They have something for everyone manga, indies, collectables, artwork, Gundam kits, you name it. The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. Always a joyful experience when I stop in.

6. 6

   In Between Pages (The next chapter of The York Emporium)

   4.8★★★★★ 522 reviews

   York, PA · 113 S Duke St
   Score 2,506 (4.8 × 522)

   The first time I tried to come here, I drove past it twice. It sits close to the rear of the parking lot, so it's not right along the street. I'm glad I made it. This is the 2nd best used bookstore in central PA (Midtown Scholar Bookstore in Harrisburg is #1).

7. 7

   New Dimension Comics - Pittsburgh Mills

   4.6★★★★★ 541 reviews

   Tarentum, PA · 590 Pittsburgh Mills Blvd Ste 220
   Score 2,489 (4.6 × 541)

   Buys comics Free Comic Book Day

   This comic book store is a true destination for collectors and enthusiasts. While it's located in an all-but-abandoned mall, don't let the location fool you—the trip is absolutely worth it.

8. 8

   Ontario Street Comics

   4.8★★★★★ 507 reviews

   Philadelphia, PA · 2235 E Ontario St
   Score 2,434 (4.8 × 507)

   Back issuesFree Comic Book Day

   Ontario Street Comics is easily the best Comic book shop in the Philadelphia area. A huge selection of back issues, collectable toys and other pop culture paraphernalia.

9. 9

   Comic Store West

   4.5★★★★★ 531 reviews

   York, PA · 2111 Industrial Hwy
   Score 2,390 (4.5 × 531)

   Back issues

   The store has just about everything. They have lots of comic books, but their game selection is extensive. The store even has games that one can not find anywhere else. The store also has a very large gaming area with plenty of seating and large tables for all kinds of game play.

10. 10

    ActionToyMan

    4.7★★★★★ 487 reviews

    Erie, PA · 1215 W 26th St
    Score 2,289 (4.7 × 487)

    Vintage & keys

    This place started off my figure collection. It is my all time favorite store. Whether you are a big time collector, common nerd, or just overall into pop culture, this store is phenomenal. They truly do not allow any blank shelf space. There are figures, board games, and comics galore.

Tags appear only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. Quotes are excerpts from public Google reviews. Ratings and review counts come from Google and change over time.

All 129 comic shops in Pennsylvania Top-rated in other states