Home › Top-rated comic shops › West Virginia

Top-rated comic book stores in West Virginia

How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 14 of the 15 comic shops we list in West Virginia qualify; these are the top 10.

Ranked from public Google numbers. Not an endorsement.

1. 1

   Four Horsemen Comics and Gaming of Morgantown

   4.5★★★★★ 708 reviews

   Morgantown, WV · 9515 Mall Rd
   Score 3,186 (4.5 × 708)

   Fantastic selection of gaming accessories. Whether you are into Magic the Gathering, D & D, or Pokémon, there is something here for you. They have been in business over 15 years and have an amazing selection of stuff. Tournaments are always fun and they have a cafe too.

2. 2

   Lost Legion Games & Comics: The Rifleman

   4.5★★★★★ 244 reviews

   South Charleston, WV · 600 D St
   Score 1,098 (4.5 × 244)

   Back issues

   Our family regularly frequents Lost Legion for our Dungeons and Dragons necessities. If you need books, miniatures, maps, etc. Lost Legion is the place to go. If they don't have what you need, they will order it for you!

3. 3

   Lost Legion Games & Comics: The Vault

   4.6★★★★★ 236 reviews

   Vienna, WV · 517 21st St
   Score 1,086 (4.6 × 236)

   Pull listsBack issues

   I have been going to Lost Legions for many years. The staff is always friendly and knowledgeable, they have a lot of good stock, and the building has a large amount of room for customers. Their pricing is also highly competitive, and they are the first place I check for supplements.

4. 4

   Third Floor Comics

   4.5★★★★★ 174 reviews

   Nitro, WV · 110 21st St
   Score 783 (4.5 × 174)

   Very cool variety shop with interesting items and i would defntly recommend checking it out, Tons of comics but no $1 or discount bins and most books aren't priced so you have to ask for each book to be looked up so there aren't really any great deals to be had.

5. 5

   Comic Paradise Plus

   4.7★★★★★ 141 reviews

   Fairmont, WV · 401 Walnut Ave
   Score 663 (4.7 × 141)

   Pull listsBack issuesIndie & small press

   Jared is knowledgeable and a born salesman (you will come in for the latest Marvel bestseller and come out with three or four Image sleepers you’ve just heard about from Jared).

6. 6

   Comic Paradise Plus 2

   4.7★★★★★ 97 reviews

   Morgantown, WV · 183 Holland Ave
   Score 456 (4.7 × 97)

   Back issuesFree Comic Book Day

   I visited this comic book shop while on a work trip looking for something to read to pass the down time. Oblivious to time, I walked it 5 minutes before they closed. The person who was working was very kind and helped me out and made a great recommendation based on my interests.

7. 7

   Fama's Coins and Baseball Cards

   4.1★★★★☆ 75 reviews

   Beckley, WV · 105 Main St
   Score 308 (4.1 × 75)

   Just discovered this place a few months ago. I live in Huntington and make trips up to do business with them. Very easy to work with. Great people. Highly recommend.

8. 8

   Cheryl's Comics & Toys

   4.8★★★★★ 52 reviews

   Charleston, WV · 5216 1/2 MacCorkle Ave SE
   Score 250 (4.8 × 52)

   Back issues

   I went to cheryl's for years when I lived in west Virginia. Loved it so much I stopped in there every week. She has an awesome selection and she is an awesome person and makes you feel welcomed. Love Cheryl's comics.

9. 9

   Brown's Corner

   4.9★★★★★ 46 reviews

   Point Pleasant, WV · 500 Main St
   Score 225 (4.9 × 46)

   Always see the best Funkos here. He'll have some you didnt know existed yet. Like a DJ Stitch playing records! I usually see his booth in the Huntington Mall and he's def the most friendly and welcoming one there, theres always a conversation usually about the Funkos.

10. 10

    Comic World

    3.7★★★★☆ 60 reviews

    Huntington, WV · 1204 4th Ave
    Score 222 (3.7 × 60)

    Back issues

    From 1989 to 1993 my mother would take me there every week for the new releases. Some of my fondest memories as a child were going to the store and buying the new releases of Spiderman, Wolverine, and X-Men.

Tags appear only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. Quotes are excerpts from public Google reviews. Ratings and review counts come from Google and change over time.

All 15 comic shops in West Virginia Top-rated in other states