Home › Top-rated comic shops › Wyoming

Top-rated comic book stores in Wyoming

How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. All 6 comic shops we list in Wyoming qualify.

Ranked from public Google numbers. Not an endorsement.

1. 1

   Olympus Games

   4.6★★★★★ 268 reviews

   Cheyenne, WY · 1710 Central Ave
   Score 1,233 (4.6 × 268)

   Clean, well-kept store with super friendly staff! Unfortunately, they don't sell individual (MTG) cards, but the staff were very helpful and even directed me to other spots in downtown that could get me the stuff I needed.

2. 2

   Collectors Hub

   4.3★★★★☆ 102 reviews

   Cheyenne, WY · 312 W 17th St
   Score 439 (4.3 × 102)

   Back issuesMangaIndie & small press

   Always a pleasant experience coming here. The lady that's always working when I visit is always happy to help and answer questions. She is knowledgeable on everything in the store and is happy to share her opinions. A nice quiet atmosphere and a great open area to enjoy it in!

3. 3

   Boss Comics

   4.8★★★★★ 37 reviews

   Carpenter, WY · 511 Co Rd 154
   Score 178 (4.8 × 37)

   Back issuesVintage & keysGrading & pressing

   Great new store in Northern CO right by city park. Drop the wife and kids off and go look through some back issues. Smaller shop but can be expected just opening. Very organized and clean. Doesnt give off that dingy 90s comic shop vibe as some of the other stores ive visited. They offer comic pressing service.

4. 4

   Spellbound Apothecary and Entertainment

   4.4★★★★☆ 19 reviews

   Casper, WY · 601 SE Wyoming Blvd Unit 1176
   Score 84 (4.4 × 19)

   Pull listsBack issues

   First of all if you find yourself looking for comics like myself and have been eagerly waiting for such a place, look no further than spell bound. Secondly if you are a connoisseur in the mystic arts they are well equipped to suit that need as well. Thirdly spell bound is more than a business, they are people.

5. 5

   Nerds4Ever

   5★★★★★ 16 reviews

   Newcastle, WY · 721 Washington Blvd
   Score 80 (5 × 16)

   MangaFree Comic Book Day

   Great Place, it is the best store in all of Newcastle Wyoming, but be warned if you enter you will leave with something!!!

6. 6

   Collectors Hub Laramie

   4.7★★★★★ 15 reviews

   Laramie, WY · 302 S 2nd St
   Score 71 (4.7 × 15)

   Manga

   - Update: Came back in days later and picked up Eye of Terror for $180 after tax (Adeptus Mechanicus - Warhammer 40k). Retail price, not on sale (is listed online for $144/before tax - $158/after tax / retail is $170/before tax which is what I paid). It's not a deal but it is instant and in my hands right now.

Tags appear only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. Quotes are excerpts from public Google reviews. Ratings and review counts come from Google and change over time.

All 6 comic shops in Wyoming Top-rated in other states