Home › Pennsylvania › Pittsburgh

Comic book stores in Pittsburgh, PA

We list 10 comic shops in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Per their reviews or own websites, 2 buy comics, 1 has pull lists and 6 carry back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.

Eide's Entertainment

1121 Penn Ave

Back issuesVintage & keysFree Comic Book Day
4.5Rating
893Reviews
4Extras

Pop Culture Comics & Toys - Pittsburgh

1105 Mt Royal Blvd

Buys comics Back issues
4.8Rating
380Reviews
2Extras

Phantom of the Attic Comics

411 S Craig St 2nd floor

4.9Rating
350Reviews
1Extras

Four Horsemen Comics and Gaming of Robinson Township

100 Robinson Centre Dr

Pull lists
4.6Rating
327Reviews
4Extras

Phantom of the Attic

2351 Noblestown Rd

Back issues
4.8Rating
259Reviews
4Extras

South Side Comics

314 1/2 Curry Hollow Rd

Back issuesManga
4.7Rating
134Reviews
4Extras

Pop Culture Comics & Toys (Sussex Ave)

3049 Sussex Ave Center Building

Buys comics
4.8Rating
121Reviews
1Extras

Geekadrome : Games and Comics

534 Brookline Blvd

Back issues
4.6Rating
119Reviews
4Extras

Doomed Planet Comics

3138 Dobson St #3

MangaIndie & small press
5Rating
25Reviews
3Extras

Mustang Comics

1705 Monongahela Ave

Back issues
4.8Rating
16Reviews
3Extras

The "Local fave" sticker marks the Pittsburgh shop with the highest Google rating times review count. It's a ranking of public numbers, not an endorsement.

Compare Pittsburgh comic shops

ShopRatingReviewsProven comic extras
Eide's Entertainment1121 Penn Ave 4.5★ 893 Back issues · Vintage & keys · Free Comic Book Day
Pop Culture Comics & Toys - Pittsburgh1105 Mt Royal Blvd 4.8★ 380 Buys comics · Back issues
Phantom of the Attic Comics411 S Craig St 2nd floor 4.9★ 350 —
Four Horsemen Comics and Gaming of Robinson Township100 Robinson Centre Dr 4.6★ 327 Pull lists
Phantom of the Attic2351 Noblestown Rd 4.8★ 259 Back issues
South Side Comics314 1/2 Curry Hollow Rd 4.7★ 134 Back issues · Manga
Pop Culture Comics & Toys (Sussex Ave)3049 Sussex Ave Center Building 4.8★ 121 Buys comics
Geekadrome : Games and Comics534 Brookline Blvd 4.6★ 119 Back issues
Doomed Planet Comics3138 Dobson St #3 5★ 25 Manga · Indie & small press
Mustang Comics1705 Monongahela Ave 4.8★ 16 Back issues

Extras show only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. A dash doesn't mean a shop lacks it.

What Pittsburgh shoppers say

Eide's Entertainment

Three levels. Absolutely massive selection. The volume of product in the store is incredible. Huge oversized section of $1 loose unsorted comic books from the 80s and 90s on the main level. Lower level has a very complete and very extensive back issue collection. They seem to have absolutely everything.

★★★★☆ Johnny, Nov 2019

Pop Culture Comics & Toys - Pittsburgh

Comics, posters, DVDs, collectibles, they have EVERYTHING. I could look around in here for hours finding endless cool stuff. A lot of it is pretty affordable too considering a lot of it is hard to find/rare items. I will absolutely be back.

★★★★★ Chase, Oct 2022

Phantom of the Attic Comics

This comic store is a true gem—easily a 5 out of 5. The selection is impressively wide, with everything from classic issues to new releases and collectibles. Customer service is superb; the staff are knowledgeable, welcoming, and clearly passionate about what they do.

★★★★★ A&T, Jun 2025

Excerpts from public Google reviews.

Selling comics in Pittsburgh?

2 Pittsburgh shops buy comics, per their reviews or their own websites: Pop Culture Comics & Toys - Pittsburgh and Pop Culture Comics & Toys (Sussex Ave).

Where to sell comics in Pittsburgh

City guide

A longer read on Pittsburgh's 10 comic shops, built from the same listings, reviews and shop websites.

Comic shops in Pittsburgh: the guide

Comic shops near Pittsburgh

Shop count and straight-line distance between city centers.

Pittsburgh comic shop FAQ

How many comic book stores are in Pittsburgh?
We list 10 comic shops in Pittsburgh, out of 129 comic shops in 94 cities across Pennsylvania.
Which Pittsburgh comic shop ranks first?
By Google rating times review count, Eide's Entertainment comes first, with 4.5★ from 893 reviews. For star rating alone (10+ reviews), Doomed Planet Comics is highest at 5★ from 25 reviews.
Where can I sell comics in Pittsburgh?
2 Pittsburgh shops buy comics, per their reviews or their own websites: Pop Culture Comics & Toys - Pittsburgh and Pop Culture Comics & Toys (Sussex Ave). Compare the Pittsburgh buyers.
Which Pittsburgh comic shops do pull lists?
Four Horsemen Comics and Gaming of Robinson Township. Its reviews or website mention pull lists or subscriptions. A pull list holds each new issue of the series you follow. How pull lists work.
Are Pittsburgh comic shops open on Sundays?
9 of the 10 with hours on Google list Sunday hours. Hours change, so check before you go.
What other towns near Pittsburgh have comic shops?
Homestead (1 shop, 5 mi), Bellevue (1 shop, 6 mi) and West View (1 shop, 6 mi).

All comic shops in Pennsylvania