Home › Top-rated comic shops › New Jersey
Top-rated comic book stores in New Jersey
How this list is ranked: each shop's Google rating multiplied by its number of Google reviews, so a shop needs both a high rating and a lot of reviews to place well. Only shops with 10 or more reviews count. 67 of the 72 comic shops we list in New Jersey qualify; these are the top 10.
Ranked from public Google numbers. Not an endorsement.
-
Jay & Silent Bob's Secret Stash
4.8★★★★★ 1,705 reviews
Back issuesSigningsI had seen the shop on Comic Book Men and had always wanted to come. This place did not disappoint. I met Mike Zapcic and the guy was absolutely awesome. When he heard that I was a fan, he went above and beyond making our visit a special one.
-
The Nerd Mall
4.7★★★★★ 664 reviews
Back issuesMangaGreat Atmosphere, Great Customer Service, and a HUGE selection of collectibles of all kinds. Pokémon of course to Original Nintendos, Magic Cards, Hockey, Baseball, etc... Xbox 360's, Comics, and the list continues!!!
-
Zapp! Comics We Buy Comics, Cards and Much More!
4.7★★★★★ 661 reviews
Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keysVery helpful and nostalgia from my childhood, still a classic great place all around. They have collected a great value of pokemon cards and magic cards. And they have a whole bunch of cool stuff for collectors of comics and the liking. Definitely check them out and they will buy your collectibles also.
-
Pandora's Box Toys & Collectibles
4.7★★★★★ 612 reviews
SigningsThis store is filled with so much nostalgia that you may not know where to begin down memory lane. There are so many wonderful and amazing items that fill the shelves. The owners are very kind and are really helpful. Each time I go to the store I leave with things that brought me so much joy as a kid.
-
The Comic Book Store
4.7★★★★★ 596 reviews
Back issuesFree Comic Book DayI'd go 4.5 if it let me. The store is great, Kevin on the game side is an awesome employee, always a pleasure to buy from him. The problems I have art super nit picky so I only wanna dock like .5, the store is VERY small, so events are rough.
-
Main Street Comics & Toys
4.8★★★★★ 562 reviews
Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keysThis is a great comic book shop. I went in for the first time since their renovation and was wowed. Spacious and clean with tons of new and back issue selection, $1 books, complete sets, lots of wall books at great prices, Magic, Pokemon, and other TCG cards, Funkos, and collectibles.
-
Dave's Time Warp Comics & Games
4.6★★★★★ 574 reviews
Buys comics Back issuesMangaMy regular gaming store. Be sure to visit on Wednesday nights for role-playing. I run a Middle Earth game. A lot of fun and plot of people
-
Joker's Child Comics
4.8★★★★★ 544 reviews
Back issuesFree Comic Book DayThis was our first time visiting Joke's Child Comics. The store is awesome!! It's filled with ton's of comic books that are exceptionally stocked in a very well organized fashion. They also have a lot of comic book related collectibles such as toys, t shirts, ect.
-
Conquest Comics
4.8★★★★★ 377 reviews
Back issuesVintage & keysIf you're a Comic fan like me and awesome old school, well from my time[not that old], they have it. Everything. Awesome statues of the best Characters. I bring my son all the time bc it's just so cool.
-
Fortress of Solitude
4.7★★★★★ 358 reviews
Back issuesOwner of this store is really cool. My son was choking on a scone, and he was on the floor not breathing. The owner, very muscular strong and tall man with glasses saved my son. Gave him mouth to mouth and even gave us a free comic! Lovely experience!
