Home › Specialties › Pull lists › New York
Comic shops with pull lists in New York
46 comic shops in New York offer pull lists, out of 163 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions pull lists; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.
Top 12 shops by rating and reviews
Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews. The other 34 are listed by city below.
I really miss that climb up the stairs to find my pull list waiting, but the rumors about the new setup have me hyped.
I have several comic pull lists with them, and they're always organized and waiting for me when I come in.
My pull list is on time and their stock in the store is always well kept.
Their selection is unmatched and the fact that I can have a pull box with them brings me joy.
The staff have great recommendations, and this is one of the few places in central New York that offer pull-lists or subscriptions of comics.
They have an online pull list so you can get exactly what you want.
Comics on the shelf are somewhat limited due to space, but they will allow pull lists without a minimum number of and can order most current titles.
More comic shops with pull lists in New York, by city
Astoria
They're always happy to hold comics for me when I call or email them and my pull list is always fulfilled.
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
Ballston Spa
Great little store to have a pull list.
Brooklyn
Interesting comic selection and they will do pull lists so I was surprised to find that out.
Chester
The self-help comic subscription system is great since I can add and remove titles on my pull list any time I want.
East Meadow
I was able to add my name to their weekly comic pull list.
Elmira
We live in NYC but have a pull list at Heroes and pick up about once every month or two when we visit relatives.
Glens Falls
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
Grand Island
Want to find the latest books, create a pull list, or want to fill in some runs, or have questions about publishers, creators, or stories?
Harrison
Plenty of back issues, a wonderful subscription service, and phenomenal staff.
Hicksville
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
Holtsville
Their prices are fantastic, half off back issue bins, 10% off new issues if you have a pull list with them.
Huntington
If you set up a hold/pull list you will never miss a new release book and he will likely hold stuff for you that he thinks you will like.
Johnson City
- Pull lists: mentioned in 4 customer reviews
Lynbrook
They helped set up a pull list and gave some great recommendations.
Massapequa
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
New Hartford
As a teenager I would spend some of my paycheck here on a weekly pull list when you could get 20 comics or more for 20 bucks.
New Paltz
I am a long time subscriber to their pull list for new comics and all of my reserved comics are waiting for me as soon as I am able to pick them up.
Patchogue
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
Poughkeepsie
They also do comic pull lists with a discount and free bag and boards.
Queensbury
And they use Geeks for Pull Box.
Rochester
Start a pull list and don't miss a single issue
If you have a regular pull list with them they cut you a really good break.
I have a pull list that he always fulfills for me and also have asked him to help me find some stuff that isn't on the basic list and he almost always comes through.
Saratoga Springs
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
Sayville
Great shop, offering loyalty for customers including a weekly "pull list" and points rewards system.
Tonawanda
My pull list is here and it's easy to use with the online app.
Troy
They're happy to help, will order comics/novels on request and drop em in your sub box, and give recommendations.
If you're a long time fan looking to start a pull list, you'll find a welcoming community.
Wantagh
- Pull lists, per the shop's website
Wappingers Falls
Everything I asked for was delivered into my comic pull list.
West Babylon
Also a great subscription service so you never miss any new comics coming out.
Williston Park
I have had my pull list here for about 7 years now and have always had great experiences and service from those running the shop during that time.
Yonkers
Add any comic to your pull list and they'll get it for you.
Pull lists in New York, by city
- Rochester4
- New York3
- Astoria2
- Troy2
- Albany1
- Ballston Spa1
- Bronx1
- Brooklyn1
- Chester1
- Croton-On-Hudson1
- East Meadow1
- Elmira1
- Forest Hills1
- Glens Falls1
- Grand Island1
- Harrison1
- Hicksville1
- Holtsville1
- Huntington1
- Johnson City1
- Lynbrook1
- Massapequa1
- New Hartford1
- New Paltz1
- New Rochelle1
- North Syracuse1
- Patchogue1
- Poughkeepsie1
- Queensbury1
- Saratoga Springs1
- Sayville1
- Smithtown1
- Syracuse1
- Tonawanda1
- Wantagh1
- Wappingers Falls1
- West Babylon1
- Williston Park1
- Yonkers1
More in New York
- Back issue comic shops in New York101
- Comic shops with manga in New York33
- Vintage and key issue comic shops in New York24
- Comic shops that host signings in New York24
- Free Comic Book Day shops in New York23
- Comic shops that help with grading in New York3
- Indie comic shops in New York13
- Where to sell comics in New York27
All comic shops in New York → · Comic shops with pull lists in every state →