Home › Specialties › Vintage & keys › New York
Vintage and key issue comic shops in New York
24 comic shops in New York sell vintage comics and key issues, out of 163 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions vintage comics or key issues; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.
Top 12 shops by rating and reviews
Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews. The other 12 are listed by city below.
I'm kinda gonna try to reboot my comic funtimes, and when I can, hit Midtown Comics GC & TS, Silver Age, Royal Collectibles Comics (ugh.
Thank you so much for the VIP treatment and I hope to see you there next time when I'm picking my 2nd round of my CGC'd out Masterpieces.
I've been shopping at Silver Age Comics for many years and they are my favorite comic book store in the city.
Every key issue you can ask for graded, non graded, signed not signed and if they don’t have it they’ll get!
If looking for back issue of silver or bronze age books this is the place I would go to.
a great selection packed with all kinds of Silver Age golden age Funko Pops action figures and you can watch them on the what app tube too
Pretty good store, with a great selection of back issues, graded comics and a lot of older books which is cool to find!
They have some older slabbed keys, a small graphic novel section, selection of back issues, weekly incentive variants, some SideShow statues, an entire wall of Funko Pop!
All key and graded issues are on displayed raw or CGC, This store has CGC bins too and prices are fair value.
More shops with vintage and key comics in New York, by city
Babylon
Great store that is very clean and organized with comics that range from the golden age era to present plus many other collectibles like sports cards and action figures.
Ballston Spa
There were lots of old comics golden age though the modern age.
Floral Park
- Vintage & keys: mentioned in 3 customer reviews
Grand Island
Got an amazing deal on a slabbed copy of Ultimate Spider-Man 1, and they even gave me a free copy of issue 2 with it!
Lake Placid
They've got a wide variety of current and vintage comics, collectibles, and cards to choose from.
Lindenhurst
The selection of Merch is always outstanding with a good mix of old, vintage, modern & new spanning toys, graded books, statues, back issues, new books ALL at great prices.
Lynbrook
Really chill guy behind the counter, found myself a cgc graded comic for a good and fair price, never thought id own one but for 30 bucks why wouldn’t I pick it up as a first.
Massapequa
I asked about key issues and horror and the staff member told me like 50 key issues they had in like two minutes!
Middle Village
They walked me through the process, let me mail them a mountain of comics, helped press and improve them and get a package together for CGC, and sure enough, I got back slabbed 9.
Rochester
Great place for vintage comics and great prices.
Smithtown
From massive vintage grails on all major comic titles to CGC modern slabs to golden / silver / bronze / copper age books I’ve never seen before - Kyle has it all!
Watertown
It's the best organized shop I've ever been to and has a huge selection of back issues and graded comics, as well as new releases.
Vintage & keys in New York, by city
More in New York
- Comic shops with pull lists in New York46
- Back issue comic shops in New York101
- Comic shops with manga in New York33
- Comic shops that host signings in New York24
- Free Comic Book Day shops in New York23
- Comic shops that help with grading in New York3
- Indie comic shops in New York13
- Where to sell comics in New York27
All comic shops in New York → · Vintage and key issue comic shops in every state →