Home › New York › West Babylon

Comic book stores in West Babylon, NY

We list 2 comic shops in West Babylon, New York. Per their reviews or own websites, 1 has pull lists and 1 carries back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.

Long Island Comics

276 Little East Neck Rd

Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
61Reviews
2Extras

Hot Flips

87-B Eads St

3.8Rating
13Reviews
1Extras

Compare West Babylon comic shops

ShopRatingReviewsProven comic extras
Long Island Comics276 Little East Neck Rd 4.6★ 61 Pull lists · Back issues
Hot Flips87-B Eads St 3.8★ 13 —

Extras show only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. A dash doesn't mean a shop lacks it.

What West Babylon shoppers say

Long Island Comics

Love this place. Frank is really nice and knowledgeable. Great selection of current and back issues.. including some amazing $1 bins. Also a great subscription service so you never miss any new comics coming out. I cant recommend them enough!

★★★★★ Louis, Oct 2025

Hot Flips

Cool fellas! The BEST place on L.I. where you'll find proper solutions to all of your comic book storage needs! Bags! Boards!Boxes! .....and more! 👍👍👍

★★★★★ Althecomicsguy, Nov 2022

Excerpts from public Google reviews.

Comic shops near West Babylon

Shop count and straight-line distance between city centers.

West Babylon comic shop FAQ

How many comic book stores are in West Babylon?
We list 2 comic shops in West Babylon, out of 163 comic shops in 104 cities across New York.
Which West Babylon comic shop ranks first?
By Google rating times review count, Long Island Comics comes first, with 4.6★ from 61 reviews.
Where can I sell comics in West Babylon?
None of the West Babylon shops we list say they buy comics in their reviews or on their websites. 27 shops elsewhere in New York do: see the New York buyers.
Which West Babylon comic shops do pull lists?
Long Island Comics. Its reviews or website mention pull lists or subscriptions. A pull list holds each new issue of the series you follow. How pull lists work.
Are West Babylon comic shops open on Sundays?
1 of the 2 with hours on Google lists Sunday hours: Long Island Comics. Hours change, so check before you go.
What other towns near West Babylon have comic shops?
Lindenhurst (2 shops, 2 mi), North Babylon (1 shop, 2 mi) and Babylon (1 shop, 2 mi).

All comic shops in New York