Home › Sell comics › New York

Where to sell comics in New York

27 comic shops in New York buy comics, out of 163 comic shops we list in the state. A shop is listed as a buyer only when its own website or its customers' reviews say it buys, and the proof is shown with each one. Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews.

27Buyers
18Cities
163All comic shops in NY

Midtown Comics Times Square

200 W 40th St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
9,782Reviews
8Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Midtown Comics Grand Central

459 Lexington Ave

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
2,198Reviews
9Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Midtown Comics Downtown

64 Fulton St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
1,451Reviews
7Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

ToyWiz

347 NY-59

Buys comics
3.9Rating
690Reviews
3Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Play the Game Read the Story

689 N Clinton St

Buys comics Back issuesManga
4.2Rating
345Reviews
5Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Squiggy's Dugout

237A Main St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.5Rating
295Reviews
6Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Queen City Book Store

3184 Main St

Buys comics Back issues
4.6Rating
270Reviews
3Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Gutter Pop Comics

1421 Hertel Ave

Buys comics Back issuesManga
4.8Rating
244Reviews
3Extras
Buying mentioned in 1 customer review

Alex's MVP Cards and Comics

1590 York Ave

Buys comics Back issues
4.1Rating
217Reviews
2Extras

He bought my small collection for a favorable price.

From a customer review

Fat Cat Comics

278 Main St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
187Reviews
4Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Androids Amazing Comics

61 Railroad Ave

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
180Reviews
3Extras

Have a a fair price for my collection.

★★★★★ Fernando, Feb 2026

The shop's website says it buys, too.

Wonderland Comics

1620 Penfield Rd

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
167Reviews
6Extras

I sold my comic book collection from childhood to Wayne last week.

★★★★★ Bill, Jun 2024

Midtown Comics Astoria Outlet

32-11 41st St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.5Rating
163Reviews
7Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Bailey's Comics

282 N Wellwood Ave

Buys comics Back issues
4.8Rating
133Reviews
4Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

October Country Comics

246 Main St #5

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
118Reviews
5Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

NY Comics

514 79th St

Buys comics Back issues
4.9Rating
92Reviews
3Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Kyle's Comics

1029 W Jericho Turnpike

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
89Reviews
4Extras

I recently had the absolute pleasure of working with Kyle from Kyle's Comics when he purchased my comic book collection, and I can't recommend them highly enough!

★★★★★ Dr, Dec 2024

The shop's website says it buys, too.

1811 Comics

56 E Spring St

Buys comics Back issues
4.5Rating
95Reviews
3Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

All Heroes Comics

4410 Lake Ave

Buys comics Back issues
4.7Rating
83Reviews
2Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

The Spider's Web Comics & Collectibles

900 NY-376 Unit N

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
67Reviews
3Extras
Buying mentioned in 1 customer review

Greenbush Out-of-Print Comics

Columbia Plaza, 501 Columbia Turnpike Ste G

Buys comics Back issues
4.9Rating
48Reviews
2Extras

I just sold my comic book collection to John and the process could not have been easier.

From a customer review

Sparkle City Comics

1625 Route 211E

Buys comics
4.6Rating
50Reviews
1Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

All About Collectibles

601 - 630 Harry L Dr

Buys comics Back issues
3.7Rating
58Reviews
3Extras

I was in a spot low on money and wayne gave me a very fair offer for my comics.

From a customer review

Sleepover Trading Co.

373 Main St

Buys comics
5Rating
41Reviews
1Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Leone’s Collectibles

612 Stone Rd

Buys comics
4.2Rating
43Reviews
2Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Spineworks Comics NYC

74-10 69th Rd #2FL

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
5Rating
32Reviews
4Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Neat Stuff Collectibles

1625 NY-211

Buys comics
5Rating
4Reviews
—Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Comic book buyers in New York, by city

Cities with two or more buyers have their own page. The others link to every comic shop in that city.

Before you go

  1. Call ahead. Ask if the shop is buying now and when the buyer is in. Set a time for a large collection.
  2. Sort your books. Order them by title and number, and put older books and keys on top.
  3. Ask for two numbers. Shops pay below resale in cash, and many offer more in store credit.
  4. Compare offers. With 27 buyers in New York, you can get a second opinion on your most valuable books.

More on pricing, condition and what shops want: where to sell comic books and how to sell your comic collection.

Buyers in nearby states

All comic shops in New York → · Comic book buyers in other states →