Home › New York › Hicksville

Comic book stores in Hicksville, NY

We list 2 comic shops in Hicksville, New York. Per their reviews or own websites, 1 has pull lists and both carry back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.

Phoenix Comics & Collectibles

107 Stewart Ave

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.7Rating
90Reviews
6Extras

Kai Doi Comics

460 Broadway Mall

Back issues
5Rating
11Reviews
3Extras

Compare Hicksville comic shops

ShopRatingReviewsProven comic extras
Phoenix Comics & Collectibles107 Stewart Ave 4.7★ 90 Pull lists · Back issues · Manga · Free Comic Book Day
Kai Doi Comics460 Broadway Mall 5★ 11 Back issues

Extras show only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. A dash doesn't mean a shop lacks it.

What Hicksville shoppers say

Phoenix Comics & Collectibles

Phoenix Comics is definitely the best place to get comic books on Long Island, by far. The owner, Peter, is one of the most knowledgeable and helpful people on the planet. Whether a life long comic book fan, or a new enthusiast, Peter can help you find exactly what you're looking for, even if you don't know yourself.

★★★★★ Audrey, Aug 2018

Kai Doi Comics

This is one of the BEST collectibles stores I’ve ever visited! From the moment I walked in, I felt like I’d stepped into a treasure trove. Whether you're into comics, trading cards, action figures, retro games, or pop culture memorabilia, this place has something that will make your inner collector light up.

★★★★★ Serena, Feb 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews.

Comic shops near Hicksville

Shop count and straight-line distance between city centers.

Hicksville comic shop FAQ

How many comic book stores are in Hicksville?
We list 2 comic shops in Hicksville, out of 163 comic shops in 104 cities across New York.
Which Hicksville comic shop ranks first?
By Google rating times review count, Phoenix Comics & Collectibles comes first, with 4.7★ from 90 reviews. For star rating alone (10+ reviews), Kai Doi Comics is highest at 5★ from 11 reviews.
Where can I sell comics in Hicksville?
None of the Hicksville shops we list say they buy comics in their reviews or on their websites. 27 shops elsewhere in New York do: see the New York buyers.
Which Hicksville comic shops do pull lists?
Phoenix Comics & Collectibles. Its reviews or website mention pull lists or subscriptions. A pull list holds each new issue of the series you follow. How pull lists work.
Are Hicksville comic shops open on Sundays?
Both shops with hours on Google list Sunday hours. Hours change, so check before you go.
What other towns near Hicksville have comic shops?
East Meadow (1 shop, 3 mi), Wantagh (1 shop, 5 mi) and Williston Park (1 shop, 5 mi).

All comic shops in New York