Home › Specialties › Pull lists › Ohio

Comic shops with pull lists in Ohio

29 comic shops in Ohio offer pull lists, out of 111 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions pull lists; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.

29Shops
24Cities
111All comic shops in OH

Top 12 shops by rating and reviews

Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews. The other 17 are listed by city below.

Packrat Comics

3864 Lattimer St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
1,013Reviews
6Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

The Laughing Ogre

4258 N High St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
962Reviews
2Extras
Pull lists: mentioned in 1 customer review

Carol & John's Comic Shop

17462 Lorain Ave

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
708Reviews
6Extras

you have the option to be on a subscription list for your favorite titles.

From a customer review

The POP! Shop: Trading Cards, Comics and Collectibles

3104 Milan Rd #1

Pull listsBack issuesFree Comic Book Day
4.6Rating
456Reviews
7Extras

I have found it difficult to find first issues of new releases at my local comic shop unless I have them on a pull list.

From a customer review

Heroes and Games

400 N High St #157

Pull listsManga
4.5Rating
379Reviews
5Extras

their website and pull list is the best I've experienced and this is easily my favorite shop in Columbus

From a customer review

All American Cards & Comics

52 Boardman-Canfield Rd

Pull listsBack issuesGrading & pressing
4.6Rating
329Reviews
7Extras

Great shop for my pull list, randy does an excellent job.

From a customer review

Up Up & Away!

9687 Kenwood Rd A

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.6Rating
297Reviews
5Extras

I don’t LOVE that they use ComicHub for their pull lists but I get it with Previews World shutting down.

★★★★ Ryan, Jul 2025

Nostalgia Ink

403 Loveland Madeira Rd

Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
274Reviews
3Extras

Also very responsive on Facebook with questions or changes to pull list.

From a customer review

Worlds Greatest Comics

5974 Westerville Rd

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
271Reviews
4Extras

Easy to set up pull list.

From a customer review

Comic Shop Plus

300 S 30th St

Pull listsFree Comic Book Day
4.6Rating
252Reviews
6Extras

They even offer subscription services so that you never miss out on a new issue of your favorite comic series.

★★★★★ Kevin, May 2018

Manga Manga

5908 Hamilton Ave

Buys comics Pull listsManga
4.9Rating
209Reviews
4Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

Up Up & Away

4016 Harrison Ave

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.6Rating
218Reviews
6Extras

For example, I wanted maestro 3 but I couldn’t put it on my pull list do to it’s avaibility.

From a customer review

More comic shops with pull lists in Ohio, by city

Akron 2 shops

  • Red Curtain Comics & Collectibles2317 Manchester Rd · ★ 4.9 (73)

    They have a great selection and good discounts on newer comics and pull lists.

    From a customer review
  • Nine Realms Comics and Gaming3900 Medina Rd R · ★ 4.9 (63)

    New comics are cover price, but you can get a 10% discount on your pull list here (though there is a store in town that gives a bigger discount on your pull).

    From a customer review

Amelia 1 shop

Barberton 1 shop

Cleveland 1 shop

  • North Coast Comics5853 Ridge Rd · ★ 4.7 (170)
    Pull lists: mentioned in 1 customer review

Columbus 1 shop

  • Collector Supreme1500 Polaris Pkwy ste 2008 · ★ 4.1 (56)

    My guy can get you anything and everything (within reason) I am on their pull list and they will have stuff ready for me within a day, if they have it.

    From a customer review

Elyria 1 shop

  • Keith's Comics394 Broad St · ★ 4.7 (173)

    Will set you up a pull file and do orders for you.

    From a customer review

Gahanna 1 shop

  • Krazzy Comics1010 N Hamilton Rd · ★ 4.8 (170)
    Pull lists, per the shop's website

Geneva 1 shop

  • Robot Zero Comics24 N Broadway · ★ 4.8 (128)
    Pull lists: mentioned in 1 customer review

Kent 1 shop

Madison 1 shop

  • Comic Book City2601 Hubbard Rd · ★ 4.8 (30)
    Pull lists: mentioned in 1 customer review

Marietta 1 shop

  • Asylum Comics212 3rd St A · ★ 4.7 (59)

    This shop orders through the monthly "Previews" catalogue and offers pull-lists for regular customers.

    From a customer review

Mentor 1 shop

  • COMICS AND FRIENDS7850 Mentor Ave Ste 1054 · ★ 4.5 (187)

    My LCS for several months now after my previous LCS kept having trouble getting my pull list right.

    From a customer review

North Canton 1 shop

  • Hazel's Heroes1664 N Main St Ste 12 · ★ 4.8 (96)

    The pull list is an amazing resource as well.

    ★★★★★ Sam, Feb 2018

Sheffield 1 shop

  • Comics Are Go5214 Detroit Rd · ★ 4.7 (205)

    Reaching the store is pretty easy via email if you want to make changes to your pull list or see something on their weekly stream that you missed.

    From a customer review

Toledo 1 shop

Trenton 1 shop

  • Wonder Comics & More100 N Miami St · ★ 4.7 (102)

    Setting up a pull list is also very easy, all you have to do is ask!

    From a customer review

Pull lists in Ohio, by city

The number is shops with pull lists; each city link opens every comic shop we list there.

More in Ohio