Home › Specialties › Pull lists › Indiana

Comic shops with pull lists in Indiana

16 comic shops in Indiana offer pull lists, out of 67 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions pull lists; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.

16Shops
12Cities
67All comic shops in IN

Top 12 shops by rating and reviews

Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews. The other 4 are listed by city below.

Books Comics & Things

2212 Maplecrest Rd

Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
350Reviews
5Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

Chimp's Comix & Video Games

919 E Winona Ave

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
326Reviews
8Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

Castle Comics and Games

2133 S 4th St

Pull listsBack issuesSignings
4.7Rating
250Reviews
6Extras

Huge selection of back issues and I haven't had any issue with my pull list for new stuff.

From a customer review

Vintage Phoenix

114 E 6th St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
214Reviews
6Extras

The only downside is that if a comic isn't already on your pull list, it's not guaranteed that you'll get a copy.

From a customer review

Mage's Comics and Games

7623 Shelby St

Pull listsBack issuesIndie & small press
4.8Rating
212Reviews
6Extras

Another plus is their easy to use website and online pull list.

From a customer review

Heroes Haven Comics & Games

296 US-20

Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
186Reviews
7Extras

Sign up for their subscription service and they'll be there for you weekly.

★★★★★ Paul, Dec 2024

Hero House Comics

1112 Prospect St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
173Reviews
5Extras

Also, I have a pull list for each week and they're always good about getting all of my books.

From a customer review

The Rcade Comics

1245 E State Blvd

Pull listsBack issuesSignings
4.7Rating
132Reviews
9Extras

They almost always have my pull list and when they do not have one of my books, they have a good reason as to why (usually problems with the distributor).

From a customer review

Comics Cubed

121 E Sycamore St

Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
119Reviews
3Extras

The owner is very nice and working with him to get a pull list going is very easy.

★★★★★ Andrew, Sep 2019

Blue Moon Comic Strikes Back

Nor-Nic Place, 2405 S Earl Ave

Pull listsBack issuesFree Comic Book Day
4.6Rating
116Reviews
4Extras

Haven't started a pull list yet, but I'm sure they will accommodate what you're looking for.

From a customer review

Books, Comics & Things

5808 W Jefferson Blvd

Pull listsFree Comic Book Day
4.6Rating
102Reviews
5Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

Atomic Planet Comics

8906 E 96th St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
97Reviews
9Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

More comic shops with pull lists in Indiana, by city

Evansville 1 shop

  • Subscription Comics4600 Vogel Rd · ★ 5 (25)

    A very well curated selection of back issues and more than reasonable pricing on pressing/cleaning/grading services and a solid discount if you get your pull list here.

    From a customer review

Huntington 1 shop

Nashville 1 shop

  • Clobberin' Comics175 S Jefferson St · ★ 5 (25)

    He even mentioned pull-list service when he learned I would be in the area for a while.

    From a customer review

Sellersburg 1 shop

  • Madd Comics400 N Indiana Ave · ★ 4.9 (39)

    They give you a 10% discount if you open up a subscription box for new comics.

    ★★★★★ Ronnie, Nov 2025

Pull lists in Indiana, by city

The number is shops with pull lists; each city link opens every comic shop we list there.

More in Indiana