Home › Specialties › Pull lists › New Jersey

Comic shops with pull lists in New Jersey

18 comic shops in New Jersey offer pull lists, out of 72 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions pull lists; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.

18Shops
17Cities
72All comic shops in NJ

Top 12 shops by rating and reviews

Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews. The other 6 are listed by city below.

East Side Mags

491 Bloomfield Ave Ste 102

Pull listsBack issuesSignings
4.7Rating
347Reviews
9Extras

Response for any changes to my pull list are always quick and the music in store is always top notch.

From a customer review

Ron's Comic World

1690 NJ-38

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
332Reviews
7Extras

They know me by name and have my pull list ready when I come in the door.

From a customer review

Comic Fortress

59 W Main St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.6Rating
320Reviews
4Extras

The owner was also very nice and helpful in explaining things such as a pull list.

From a customer review

Manifest Comics

766 Broadway Apt 3

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.7Rating
267Reviews
6Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

A&S Comics

563 Cedar Ln

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
215Reviews
4Extras

At A&S they helped out by answering my questions and they have a pull list and rewards system for regulars.

From a customer review

The Toy & Comic Spot

1889 NJ-88

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.9Rating
206Reviews
8Extras
Pull lists, per the shop's website

Comic Crypt LLC

73 NJ-35

Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
211Reviews
4Extras

Frequent the store once a week and the owner has my own pull list so I don't even have to take off the shelves and provides a discount to frequent members.

From a customer review

Secret Origins Comics & More

888 Haddon Ave

Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
210Reviews
3Extras

The pull list is a thing were you can pull new comics that come out that week and he will keep one aside for you so you can get it when you go next.

From a customer review

A & S Comics & Cards

7512 Bergenline Ave

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.7Rating
190Reviews
4Extras

It's my weekly spot for my pull list.

From a customer review

the geekery

19 Little St

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
154Reviews
6Extras

I highly recommend this shop for both regular purchases and a pull list!

From a customer review

Comic Relief

4120 Quakerbridge Rd

Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
152Reviews
3Extras
Pull lists: mentioned in 1 customer review

Crossroad Comics and Collectibles

23 S Broadway

Pull listsBack issuesFree Comic Book Day
4.8Rating
145Reviews
4Extras

A very respectable selection of back issue comics and they offer subscription services.

From a customer review

More comic shops with pull lists in New Jersey, by city

Flemington 1 shop

  • Comic Fusion16 Turntable Jct · ★ 4.5 (118)

    I've had a pull list here for years and have nothing but good things to say about Comic Fusion.

    From a customer review

Howell Township 1 shop

Lawrence Township 1 shop

  • Final Boss Comics & Games10 Gordon Ave · ★ 5 (116)

    If you have a weekly pull list they even include free bags and boards, very nice touch!

    ★★★★★ William, Nov 2022

Little Egg Harbor Township 1 shop

  • Neon Mermaid Comics240 Mathistown Rd #110 · ★ 5 (31)

    They offer subscription services, too!

    ★★★★★ Rosanne, Jan 2025

Maplewood 1 shop

  • Magnus Comics155 Maplewood Ave Fl 2 · ★ 4.8 (84)

    Highly recommend signing up for their pull list every week.

    From a customer review

Medford 1 shop

  • Mutation Comics & MoreThe Shoppes at Medford Mill Mutation Comics, 18 Charles St Unit I · ★ 4.5 (11)

    The store has a good selection of comics, but the real game-changer is the pull box service.

    From a customer review

Pull lists in New Jersey, by city

The number is shops with pull lists; each city link opens every comic shop we list there.

More in New Jersey