Home › Sell comics › New Jersey

Where to sell comics in New Jersey

10 comic shops in New Jersey buy comics, out of 72 comic shops we list in the state. A shop is listed as a buyer only when its own website or its customers' reviews say it buys, and the proof is shown with each one. Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews.

10Buyers
10Cities
72All comic shops in NJ

Zapp! Comics We Buy Comics, Cards and Much More!

574 Valley Rd

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
661Reviews
5Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Main Street Comics & Toys

74 N Main St

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.8Rating
562Reviews
4Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Dave's Time Warp Comics & Games

555A Pompton Ave

Buys comics Back issuesManga
4.6Rating
574Reviews
5Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Farpoint Toys & Collectibles

5113 Harding Hwy

Buys comics SigningsFree Comic Book Day
4.8Rating
276Reviews
3Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

The Toy & Comic Spot

1889 NJ-88

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.9Rating
206Reviews
8Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

True Believers (Formally Wize Guys Collectibles)

713 Bloomfield Ave

Buys comics
4.4Rating
84Reviews
2Extras
Buying mentioned in 1 customer review

Camptown Coins & Collectibles

326 Wanaque Ave

Buys comics
4.4Rating
64Reviews
2Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Robbie’s Comics & Cards! We are BUYING!

142 Main St #4

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
44Reviews
4Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

NJ Comic Stop

1308 N Delaware St

Buys comics Back issues
5Rating
36Reviews
2Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Toytastik

545 Commerce St Unit A

Buys comics
4.5Rating
8Reviews
1Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Comic book buyers in New Jersey, by city

Cities with two or more buyers have their own page. The others link to every comic shop in that city.

Before you go

  1. Call ahead. Ask if the shop is buying now and when the buyer is in. Set a time for a large collection.
  2. Sort your books. Order them by title and number, and put older books and keys on top.
  3. Ask for two numbers. Shops pay below resale in cash, and many offer more in store credit.
  4. Compare offers. With 10 buyers in New Jersey, you can get a second opinion on your most valuable books.

More on pricing, condition and what shops want: where to sell comic books and how to sell your comic collection.

Buyers in nearby states

All comic shops in New Jersey → · Comic book buyers in other states →