Home › Specialties › Vintage & keys › New Jersey

Vintage and key issue comic shops in New Jersey

12 comic shops in New Jersey sell vintage comics and key issues, out of 72 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions vintage comics or key issues; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.

12Shops
12Cities
72All comic shops in NJ

All 12 shops, by city

Conquest Comics

657 US-9

Back issuesVintage & keys
4.8Rating
377Reviews
3Extras

Current issues, back issues, trade paperbacks, graded books, and classic issues which are meticulously organized.

From a customer review

Frankenstein Comics

5200 NJ-42

Back issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
103Reviews
2Extras

And trust me when I say Silver and Bronze Age books are so reasonably priced.

From a customer review

Robbie’s Comics & Cards! We are BUYING!

142 Main St #4

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
44Reviews
4Extras

I picked up some vintage comics, a few nice Kobe/Shaq cards, and even some new tcg sets!

From a customer review

The Toy & Comic Spot

1889 NJ-88

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.9Rating
206Reviews
8Extras

The action figure selection is quite large and they carry many comics, back issues, and slabs.

From a customer review

Batcave comix & collectables

2954 US-9

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
41Reviews
4Extras

This is a can't miss for any comic book fans, their selection is amazing and I have found so many key issues there.

★★★★★ Samir, Jul 2026

Magnus Comics

155 Maplewood Ave Fl 2

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.8Rating
84Reviews
4Extras

Whether it’s a specific key issue or just recommendations, he’s got you covered.

From a customer review

the geekery

19 Little St

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
154Reviews
6Extras

Update 10/12/22 Doug and Justin have recently expanded their collection, separating out the Silver and Bronze Age books from the Modern books.

From a customer review

Main Street Comics & Toys

74 N Main St

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.8Rating
562Reviews
4Extras

CGC slabs as well as a great selection of pop and action figures.

From a customer review

Ron's Comic World

1690 NJ-38

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
332Reviews
7Extras

Whether you’re searching for key issues, vintage collectibles, or just chasing that Saturday morning comic shop feeling, this place delivers.

From a customer review

A&S Comics

563 Cedar Ln

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
215Reviews
4Extras

The gentleman that helped me kindly gave me a quick crash course on vintage comics and how to know if they were worth getting graded.

★★★★★ Guillermo, Oct 2021

Comic Relief of Toms River

1341 Lakewood Rd #9

Back issuesVintage & keys
4.6Rating
307Reviews
4Extras

The selection of back issues and slabbed books are amazing.

★★★★★ Peter, Apr 2025

Zapp! Comics We Buy Comics, Cards and Much More!

574 Valley Rd

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.7Rating
661Reviews
5Extras

Whether you’re looking for high end grails, vintage back issues, new releases, modern sets, slabs, or any TCG / toys - zapp has you covered.

From a customer review

Vintage & keys in New Jersey, by city

The number is shops with vintage comics or key issues; each city link opens every comic shop we list there.

More in New Jersey