Home › New Jersey › Eatontown › Comic Crypt LLC

Comic Crypt LLC Comic book store in Eatontown, NJ

4.7 ★★★★★ 211 Google reviews

Pull listsBack issues

Comic Crypt LLC is a comic book store at 73 NJ-35, Eatontown, NJ. It has a 4.7-star rating from 211 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it offers pull lists and back issues.

What it's known for

Each item is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • Pull lists & subscriptions

    More comic shops with pull lists →

    “Frequent the store once a week and the owner has my own pull list so I don't even have to take off the shelves and provides a discount to frequent members.”

    Google review · Mentioned once in reviews

  • “A lot of back issues to choose from and just has a type of nostalgia to it.”

    Google review · Mentioned 6 times in reviews

Also on the shelves

  • Also sells trading cards

    “I came for Magic the Gathering cards/decks, but they had a very small selection and no longer did drafts, due to attendance.”

    Google review · Mentioned 6 times in reviews

  • Toys & collectibles

    “Friendly, knowledgeable and funny staff and lots of product like Magic The Gathering cards, Pokemon, Funko-Pops, etc.”

    Google review · Mentioned 10 times in reviews

From Google reviews

(premise: I've been In The Comic Crypt at Collingwood, Flea market) I'm on holiday from Italy and I bought some action figures then I returned some minutes later and bought more action figures. The place is magical and the staff (I met Brian) has been unique and super polite with my questions and items research.

★★★★★ Daniele, Jun 2024

Absolutely loved my first experience here and I will 100% be returning in the future. There is such a wide variety of comics all neatly organized and easy to navigate. The staff is very friendly. It's located very conveniently with a large parking lot. They also offer dollar comics out of the package.

★★★★★ Anna, Aug 2024

Fantastic shop with vintage, back-issue selection. The owner was in and cut me a fair deal on a 1940s' Teen/Romance comic I was interested in, can't ask for a better experience than that! Would always come in this shop, helpful staff and back issues galore.

★★★★★ William, Jun 2026

Great shop! Lots of used comics, and a pretty insane collection of toys rotating through.

★★★★★ Mike, Jul 2025

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 211 on Google →

Where to find Comic Crypt LLC

More comic shops nearby

Jay & Silent Bob's Secret Stash

65 Broad St

Back issuesSignings
4.8Rating
1,705Reviews
4Extras

3.5 miles away

Unwind Records and Comics

1100 Ocean Ave N Unit d

Manga
4.8Rating
35Reviews
1Extras

6.2 miles away

Jersey Coin Showcase

1350 NJ-36

4.5Rating
112Reviews
2Extras

11.2 miles away

the geekery

19 Little St

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
154Reviews
6Extras

12.0 miles away

Operation Doomsday Comics

700 Tennent Rd

Back issuesFree Comic Book DayIndie & small press
4.7Rating
292Reviews
5Extras

13.2 miles away

Batcave comix & collectables

2954 US-9

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
41Reviews
4Extras

13.2 miles away

All comic shops in Eatontown, NJ →

Comic shops in nearby cities

All comic shops in New Jersey →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.