Home › Indiana › Evansville

Comic book stores in Evansville, IN

We list 3 comic shops in Evansville, Indiana. Per their reviews or own websites, 1 has pull lists and all 3 carry back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.

The Book Broker

2717 Covert Ave

Back issuesSigningsFree Comic Book Day
4.3Rating
705Reviews
6Extras

Comic Quest

8401 N Kentucky Ave

Back issuesManga
4.5Rating
634Reviews
6Extras

Subscription Comics

4600 Vogel Rd

Pull listsBack issuesManga
5Rating
25Reviews
5Extras

The "Local fave" sticker marks the Evansville shop with the highest Google rating times review count. It's a ranking of public numbers, not an endorsement.

Compare Evansville comic shops

ShopRatingReviewsProven comic extras
The Book Broker2717 Covert Ave 4.3★ 705 Back issues · Signings · Free Comic Book Day
Comic Quest8401 N Kentucky Ave 4.5★ 634 Back issues · Manga
Subscription Comics4600 Vogel Rd 5★ 25 Pull lists · Back issues · Manga · Vintage & keys · Grading & pressing

Extras show only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. A dash doesn't mean a shop lacks it.

What Evansville shoppers say

The Book Broker

Great old bookstore. It's moved into other used media, and comic books since I visited last before they moved. Glad to see the book selection is still there. I didn't have time or energy to get to all of the stuff, as i don't do stairs. Next time.

★★★★★ Jim, May 2023

Comic Quest

Awesome comic hobby gaming store. Had lots of options for games pops mtg singles ect. Places felt like a nerd haven and the customer server was great staff very friendly. Will shop again here!!

★★★★★ J, Aug 2022

Subscription Comics

What can I say...Aaron is simply the best. I travelled over from Louisville to him because he spent over an hour on the phone with me walking through CGC comic submission processes. Told me to drop by anytime and he'd help me through it all in person.

★★★★★ Nathan, Jan 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews.

Comic shops near Evansville

Shop count and straight-line distance between city centers.

Evansville comic shop FAQ

How many comic book stores are in Evansville?
We list 3 comic shops in Evansville, out of 67 comic shops in 44 cities across Indiana.
Which Evansville comic shop ranks first?
By Google rating times review count, The Book Broker comes first, with 4.3★ from 705 reviews. For star rating alone (10+ reviews), Subscription Comics is highest at 5★ from 25 reviews.
Where can I sell comics in Evansville?
None of the Evansville shops we list say they buy comics in their reviews or on their websites. 3 shops elsewhere in Indiana do: see the Indiana buyers.
Which Evansville comic shops do pull lists?
Subscription Comics. Its reviews or website mention pull lists or subscriptions. A pull list holds each new issue of the series you follow. How pull lists work.
Are Evansville comic shops open on Sundays?
1 of the 3 with hours on Google lists Sunday hours: Comic Quest. Hours change, so check before you go.
What other towns near Evansville have comic shops?
Henderson, KY (2 shops, 12 mi), Owensboro, KY (2 shops, 28 mi) and White Plains, KY (1 shop, 57 mi).

All comic shops in Indiana