Comic book stores in Indianapolis, IN
We list 8 comic shops in Indianapolis, Indiana. Per their reviews or own websites, 1 buys comics, 2 have pull lists and all 8 carry back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.
Compare Indianapolis comic shops
| Shop | Rating | Reviews | Proven comic extras |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comic Carnival7235 N Keystone Ave Ste e | 4.7★ | 378 | Buys comics · Back issues |
| Downtown Comics11 E Market St | 4.4★ | 321 | Back issues · Manga |
| Downtown Comics In Castleton5767 E 86th St | 4.4★ | 297 | Back issues · Manga · Free Comic Book Day |
| Mage's Comics and Games7623 Shelby St | 4.8★ | 212 | Pull lists · Back issues · Indie & small press |
| Hero House Comics1112 Prospect St | 4.8★ | 173 | Pull lists · Back issues · Manga · Free Comic Book Day |
| Comics Elite5575 Elmwood Ave E2 | 3.9★ | 193 | Back issues · Grading & pressing |
| Raven's Comics, Collectibles & Books2016 E Southport Rd #1 | 4.7★ | 53 | Back issues · Vintage & keys |
| O-Dog Comics8914 Southeastern Ave | 5★ | 6 | Back issues |
What Indianapolis shoppers say
I have been a customer here since 2009. You can not find a better comic book store in my opinion. They know me by name and are always willing to order me things of they don't have them. They have games on the weekends and the staff and owners are the friendliest folks you'll meet.
Great NEW COMIC PLACE….lots of choices on covers from Indie to classic. This is a new readers store for sure. There are many back issue bins to look through including some nice bargain bins. Be prepared for bagging and boarding loose comics in bins.
Jo is phenomenal. She provides the kindest and most thoughtful customer service I have ever received while buying comics. A truly fun and unforgettable experience. Worth the trip from Chicago.
Selling comics in Indianapolis?
Comic Carnival buys comics, per its reviews or its own website. 3 shops across Indiana do.
Where to sell comics in IndianaComic shops near Indianapolis
- Beech Grove 1 · 3 mi
- Speedway 1 · 9 mi
- Greenwood 1 · 11 mi
- Fishers 1 · 13 mi
- Avon 1 · 15 mi
- Camby 1 · 15 mi
- Brownsburg 1 · 16 mi
- Greenfield 2 · 17 mi
Indianapolis comic shop FAQ
- How many comic book stores are in Indianapolis?
- We list 8 comic shops in Indianapolis, out of 67 comic shops in 44 cities across Indiana.
- Which Indianapolis comic shop ranks first?
- By Google rating times review count, Comic Carnival comes first, with 4.7★ from 378 reviews. For star rating alone (10+ reviews), Mage's Comics and Games is highest at 4.8★ from 212 reviews.
- Where can I sell comics in Indianapolis?
- Comic Carnival buys comics, per its reviews or its own website. Call ahead with a rough count of what you have.
- Which Indianapolis comic shops do pull lists?
- 2 shops: Mage's Comics and Games and Hero House Comics. Their reviews or websites mention pull lists or subscriptions. A pull list holds each new issue of the series you follow. How pull lists work.
- Are Indianapolis comic shops open on Sundays?
- 6 of the 7 with hours on Google list Sunday hours. Hours change, so check before you go.
- What other towns near Indianapolis have comic shops?
- Beech Grove (1 shop, 3 mi), Speedway (1 shop, 9 mi) and Greenwood (1 shop, 11 mi).