Home › Specialties › Back issues › Indiana

Back issue comic shops in Indiana

44 comic shops in Indiana carry back issues, out of 67 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions back issues; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.

44Shops
30Cities
67All comic shops in IN

Top 12 shops by rating and reviews

Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews. The other 32 are listed by city below.

The Book Broker

2717 Covert Ave

Back issuesSigningsFree Comic Book Day
4.3Rating
705Reviews
6Extras
Back issues: mentioned in 2 customer reviews

Comic Quest

8401 N Kentucky Ave

Back issuesManga
4.5Rating
634Reviews
6Extras

Set up a weekly pull for comics, preorder items that aren't out yet, or browse a wealth of back issues, pop figures, Manga, anime, role-playing, and tabletop hobby games.

From a customer review

Hometown Comics & Games

1040 N State St

Back issuesManga
4.7Rating
549Reviews
6Extras

Over 300+ New comics on the wall and massive backissue collection.

From a customer review

Galactic Greg's

1407 Lincolnway

Buys comics Back issues
4.6Rating
470Reviews
5Extras

Great place, good selection of back issues and current comics along with ttrpg and tcg selections great staff that is very helpful

★★★★★ Xxinsaneloboxx, May 2023

Comic Carnival

7235 N Keystone Ave Ste e

Buys comics Back issues
4.7Rating
378Reviews
2Extras

Endless rows of back issues, cleanly alphabetized and deep, dollar bins that are actually sorted, and a strong new release wall.

From a customer review

Books Comics & Things

2212 Maplecrest Rd

Pull listsBack issues
4.6Rating
350Reviews
5Extras

Fairly priced at around market value for back issues and models.

★★★★★ Debbie, Apr 2018

Chimp's Comix & Video Games

919 E Winona Ave

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
326Reviews
8Extras

He has a veritable sea of back issue boxes that are easy to navigate, as well as video games, board games, action figures, and hard to find key comics.

From a customer review

Downtown Comics

11 E Market St

Back issuesManga
4.4Rating
321Reviews
5Extras

There are many back issue bins to look through including some nice bargain bins.

★★★★★ John, Sep 2024

Downtown Comics In Castleton

5767 E 86th St

Back issuesMangaFree Comic Book Day
4.4Rating
297Reviews
5Extras
Back issues, per the shop's website

The Danger Room

833 E 53rd St

Back issuesMangaIndie & small press
4.4Rating
270Reviews
6Extras

They have a decent selection of back issues and a whole lot of space for gaming.

From a customer review

Castle Comics and Games

2133 S 4th St

Pull listsBack issuesSignings
4.7Rating
250Reviews
6Extras

Not to mention the great stock of back issues, games, and more that make for great browsing.

From a customer review

Screaming Monkey Comics

11 Ridge Rd

Back issues
4.8Rating
240Reviews
5Extras

The $1 bin comics are a steal, and the toy selection is epic!

★★★★★ Jose, Jul 2024

More comic shops with back issues in Indiana, by city

Aurora 1 shop

  • Kryptos Comix311 2nd St Second Floor · ★ 4.5 (36)

    They've got a big selection of back issues that you can spend hours picking through.

    From a customer review

Avon 1 shop

  • Downtown Comics in Avon8100 E US Hwy 36 · ★ 4.5 (198)

    they do have back issues also.

    ★★★★★ Jeremy, Dec 2021

Bloomington 1 shop

  • Vintage Phoenix114 E 6th St · ★ 4.8 (214)

    My husband got me into comics and I now have my own collection of comics because of the deals they have such as the $1 bins.

    From a customer review

Columbia City 1 shop

  • B.E. Comics217 W Van Buren St Suite #1 · ★ 4.8 (32)

    Love going in to dig thru backstock.

    From a customer review

Crawfordsville 1 shop

  • Bearded Comics & Collectibles101 E Main St · ★ 4.9 (68)

    I was impressed with the amount of back issues and found 2 books that I haven't been able to find in the Indy area shops.

    From a customer review

Evansville 1 shop

  • Subscription Comics4600 Vogel Rd · ★ 5 (25)

    A very well curated selection of back issues and more than reasonable pricing on pressing/cleaning/grading services and a solid discount if you get your pull list here.

    From a customer review

Fishers 1 shop

  • Atomic Planet Comics8906 E 96th St · ★ 4.8 (97)

    Customer service is out of this world, back issues selection is fantastic, and their knowledge of comics is massive.

    ★★★★★ C, Dec 2025

Fort Wayne 3 shops

  • The Rcade Comics1245 E State Blvd · ★ 4.7 (132)

    ), the selection of back issues and collectibles was vast, and that space—how cool (an old firehouse?

    From a customer review
  • Berndt Comics & toys625 W Coliseum Blvd · ★ 4.4 (36)

    Just picked up some flash, green arrow, and punisher back issues.

    ★★★★★ The, Jun 2023
  • Summit Comics & Games4201 Coldwater Rd Ste F1 · ★ 5 (23)

    Summit is a fantastic place for comics new and backissue, TTRPGs, TCGs, and Funko collectors.

    ★★★★★ Aaron, Apr 2026

Griffith 1 shop

  • Creative Comics216 E Main St · ★ 4.7 (208)

    Collected auction winnings and hit up the $1 back issues.

    From a customer review

Hammond 1 shop

  • Happy Day Comics3537 Orchard Dr · ★ 4.9 (104)

    Really nice store, probably the best organized $1 bins I have ever seen.

    From a customer review

Huntington 1 shop

  • Corn Coast Comics23 E Market St · ★ 4.8 (92)

    TONS of well organized back issues ALL the new stuff and an amazing staff that makes shopping in person a great experience.

    From a customer review

Indianapolis 5 shops

  • Mage's Comics and Games7623 Shelby St · ★ 4.8 (212)

    I was particularly pleased with their back issue selection – I even found a few Silver Age books I'd been hunting for!

    From a customer review
  • Hero House Comics1112 Prospect St · ★ 4.8 (173)

    A superior collection of golden books and a great aspect of fountain square, this store is your basic, cherished collection of graphic novels and back issues.

    From a customer review
  • Comics Elite5575 Elmwood Ave E2 · ★ 3.9 (193)
    Back issues, per the shop's website
  • Raven's Comics, Collectibles & Books2016 E Southport Rd #1 · ★ 4.7 (53)

    This store has more back issues and good old comics then most of the big comic stores plus it has a cool book store in the back.

    ★★★★★ John, Apr 2019
  • O-Dog Comics8914 Southeastern Ave · ★ 5 (6)
    Back issues, per the shop's website

Kokomo 1 shop

  • Comics Cubed121 E Sycamore St · ★ 4.8 (119)

    They have a huge back issue selection.

    From a customer review

Lafayette 1 shop

  • Blue Moon Comic Strikes BackNor-Nic Place, 2405 S Earl Ave · ★ 4.6 (116)

    The owners are super nice/friendly and they have a good selection of books, though, this is not the place to find back issues.

    From a customer review

Logansport 1 shop

  • Savini Comics430 E Broadway · ★ 4.5 (16)
    Back issues: mentioned in 2 customer reviews

Michigan City 1 shop

Muncie 2 shops

  • Aw Yeah Comics119 E Charles St · ★ 4.7 (196)

    If you're looking for new and upcoming releases, that show is usually on Tuesdays and their live show with back issues and some new issues on Mondays.

    From a customer review
  • Bob's Comic Castle2150 W White River Blvd · ★ 4.6 (38)
    Back issues: mentioned in 1 customer review

Nashville 1 shop

  • Clobberin' Comics175 S Jefferson St · ★ 5 (25)

    The back issues were organized and easy to browse, and the prices I saw were fair.

    From a customer review

Noblesville 1 shop

  • Collectors Emporium17681 Cumberland Rd · ★ 4.7 (173)

    Graded, new, and back issue comics, cards, records, and other fun collectibles.

    From a customer review

Plymouth 1 shop

  • FYC Comics118 N Michigan St · ★ 4.9 (51)

    Carries an expansive back stock.

    From a customer review

Richmond 1 shop

  • Comic Relief100 N 9th St · ★ 4.5 (92)

    Great shop, particularly for back issues - I think I spent an hour flipping through what are likely the best dollar bins I've seen in a long time.

    From a customer review

Sellersburg 1 shop

  • Madd Comics400 N Indiana Ave · ★ 4.9 (39)

    Awesome shop and bigger than you might think from outside, lots of back issues.

    From a customer review

Shelbyville 1 shop

  • Man Cave Comics and Collectibles1310 Miller Ave · ★ 4.7 (87)

    A large amount of back issues here, but they're not easy to look through.

    From a customer review

Speedway 1 shop

  • Prideland Comics & Collectibles LLC5668 Crawfordsville Rd Ste D · ★ 4.6 (74)

    I found a rare back issue at a good price and everyone working there was very friendly and helpful.

    From a customer review

West Lafayette 1 shop

  • Von's Comics317 W State St · ★ 4.1 (31)

    They had 50% off back issues and as I said in the beginning the staff is super friendly and helpful.

    From a customer review

Back issues in Indiana, by city

The number is shops with back issues; each city link opens every comic shop we list there.

More in Indiana