City guide · New York
Comic shops in Brooklyn, NY
The directory lists 12 comic shops in Brooklyn, New York. Going by customer reviews and the shops' own websites, one offers pull lists, 8 sell back issues and 4 carry manga. One shop, NY Comics, buys comic collections, according to its reviews or website. Ranked by rating × review count, Bulletproof Comics comes first, with 4.7★ from 572 Google reviews.
12Shops
1Pull lists
8Back issues
4Manga
1Buys comics
At a glance
A check means a customer review or the shop's own website shows it; click it to see the proof. A blank means we haven't seen proof yet, not that the shop doesn't offer it. Call to ask.
| Shop | Rating | Pull lists | Back issues | Manga | Buys comics |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bulletproof Comics | 4.7★ | ||||
| Anyone Comics | 4.8★ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| Desert Island | 4.8★ | ||||
| Galaxy Collectibles | 4.6★ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| St. Mark's Comics | 3.6★ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| Vinyl Fantasy | 4.6★ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| PopFuzz | 4.5★ | ||||
| Action City Comics | 4.8★ | ✓ | |||
| Comic Book Station | 4.7★ | ✓ | |||
| NY Comics | 4.9★ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| Pinocchio Collectibles | 4.8★ | ✓ | |||
| Slope Comic & Collectibles | 4.5★ | ✓ |
All 12 comic shops in Brooklyn
Sorted by rating × number of Google reviews, which favors shops with many good reviews over a handful of perfect ones.
What each shop is known for
A specialty shows up here only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it. Quotes are verbatim sentences from 4 and 5 star Google reviews. Each shop's listing has the rest: hours, photos and any extras, such as toys and collectibles.
Anyone Comics
-
The shopkeeper, I think his name is Dmitri, was friendly and saw that I was looking at back issues.
Desert Island
-
Desert island is one of the best resources for independent comics in New York City.
Galaxy Collectibles
-
The team is friendly and knowledgable, they have the manga, comics and Pokemon cards for the kids with an awesome toy selection for myself.
St. Mark's Comics
-
A vast range of back issues, from $1 to many hundreds of dollars, countless new and vintage toys, and a very welcoming, modern atmosphere.
Vinyl Fantasy
-
Interesting comic selection and they will do pull lists so I was surprised to find that out.
-
It’s been great to see it grow over the years and I love the variety of indie comics available.
Action City Comics
-
Great range of well cared for back issues, a plethora of toys, and all the modern issues you could ask for.
Comic Book Station
-
I got there ,( took me almost 1 hour from my home ) and someone was working inside on the area on the dollar comics so no way to go browse anything , nowhere they say that .
-
All key and graded issues are on displayed raw or CGC, This store has CGC bins too and prices are fair value.
NY Comics
-
They have a lot of back issues of highly sought after key comics with a stock that is replenished through trade ins and sales!
Pinocchio Collectibles
-
Great collection of back issues, this place has a ton of charm and has been around for over 40 years.
Slope Comic & Collectibles
-
I was mainly interested in their dollar bins downstairs, but I saw there was a sign for a World Cup trading card event.
Selling comics in Brooklyn
One shop here buys comic collections, going by customer reviews or the shop's own website. Policies change and some shops only buy certain books, so call before you bring boxes in.
Before you go, read how to sell your comic collection. See every shop that buys comics in New York.
More in New York
Nearby cities with comic shops
All Brooklyn comic shop listings Comic shops in New York More guides