Home › Specialties › Vintage & keys › Ohio

Vintage and key issue comic shops in Ohio

12 comic shops in Ohio sell vintage comics and key issues, out of 111 comic shops we list in the state. Each one is here because a customer review or the shop's own website mentions vintage comics or key issues; the proof is under each shop. Call ahead before a long drive, since what a shop offers can change.

12Shops
12Cities
111All comic shops in OH

All 12 shops, by city

Red Curtain Comics & Collectibles

2317 Manchester Rd

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
73Reviews
6Extras

There is likely not a better selection of new issues and key issues (graded or ungraded) anywhere around.

From a customer review

Watchtower Heroes Comics

6 S Main St

Back issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
85Reviews
3Extras

Very organized, good key wall with some graded books, good raws as well.

From a customer review

Collector Supreme

1500 Polaris Pkwy ste 2008

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.1Rating
56Reviews
4Extras

His new comic shop is stunning, organized, bright, and loaded with comics (plenty of raw & slabs), trades & graphic novels, toys, cards, supplies, and more!

From a customer review

Old Codger's Comics

Inside Antiques Village Booth 6015, 651 Lyons Rd, 6020 Showcase 6

Back issuesVintage & keys
5Rating
9Reviews
2Extras

They have an awesome selection and variety of comics, I was able to complete multiple runs of silver age horror and modern superhero comics at reasonable prices.

★★★★★ Dave, Sep 2025

Bookery Fantasy Collectibles

16 W Main St

Buys comics Back issuesVintage & keys
4.6Rating
426Reviews
5Extras
Vintage & keys: mentioned in 2 customer reviews

COMICS AND FRIENDS

7850 Mentor Ave Ste 1054

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keys
4.5Rating
187Reviews
5Extras

Great amount of vintage comics that I have purchased there to and collected editions.

From a customer review

Freedom Comics

2223 W Laskey Rd

Back issuesMangaVintage & keys
4.7Rating
235Reviews
6Extras

If you want highly knowledgeable staff/owners that will share in your passion for comics, action figures, posters, graded comics, new comics, old comics and collectibles.

★★★★★ Becky, Jan 2025

All American Cards & Comics

161 W Market St

Back issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
380Reviews
5Extras

Lots of silver age keys, which is what I'm into.

From a customer review

Jim & Dan Comics and Collectibles

1 E Dayton St

Back issuesVintage & keys
4.9Rating
111Reviews
3Extras

They have a huge selection of new and vintage comics, great prices, and the owners are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable.

From a customer review

Worlds Greatest Comics

5974 Westerville Rd

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
271Reviews
4Extras

They have a great selection of Comics, CGC Slabs, Trade Paper Backs and Figures and because of that it makes it very hard not to spend hours looking around the store!

From a customer review

Comic Heaven

4847 Robinhood Dr

Back issuesMangaVintage & keys
4.6Rating
227Reviews
4Extras

Friendly, approachable and helpful staff good selection of key issues and cool selection of toys

From a customer review

Mass Media Comics, LLC

631 Main St

Back issuesVintage & keys
5Rating
59Reviews
4Extras

They do better than any other shop I’ve been to at putting notes on the book’s bag to explain what makes them important if they are a key issue.

From a customer review

Vintage & keys in Ohio, by city

The number is shops with vintage comics or key issues; each city link opens every comic shop we list there.

More in Ohio