Home › Ohio › Columbus › Collector Supreme

Collector Supreme Comic book store in Columbus, OH

4.1 ★★★★☆ 56 Google reviews

Pull listsBack issuesVintage & keysGrading & pressing

Collector Supreme is a comic book store at 1500 Polaris Pkwy ste 2008, Columbus, OH. It has a 4.1-star rating from 56 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it offers pull lists, back issues, vintage & keys and grading & pressing.

What it's known for

Each item is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • Pull lists & subscriptions

    More comic shops with pull lists →

    “My guy can get you anything and everything (within reason) I am on their pull list and they will have stuff ready for me within a day, if they have it.”

    Google review · Mentioned 2 times in reviews

  • “They are offering a discounted pull service for new books and have some backstock issues (some are not yet tagged, but they'll price them at the counter).”

    Google review · Mentioned 4 times in reviews

  • “His new comic shop is stunning, organized, bright, and loaded with comics (plenty of raw & slabs), trades & graphic novels, toys, cards, supplies, and more!”

    Google review · Mentioned 7 times in reviews

  • “I will definitely be coming back, and not just for the CGC books I dropped off.”

    Google review · Mentioned 2 times in reviews

From Google reviews

Huge selection and some rare finds in great condition. Warms my heart to see someone opening up a pure comic book store in a major mall these days. Best of luck.

★★★★★ Brian, Nov 2023

Stopped in and talked to Rich and what can I say? He was great. Sometimes people in comic shops don't give the best customer service and this place was as good as it gets. Very well laid-out store and easy to shop there as well. A+ and highly recommended. Thanks for being awesome, Collector Supreme!

★★★★★ Cale, Jun 2025

Went to Polaris Mall and did a little Holiday shopping with the Mrs and guess who I ran into?!? Joe from @collectorsupreme_ on Instagram. Joe has been a part of our online comic community for a while, hosting his own sales, and also a regular seller with @elite_comics11.

★★★★★ Daniel, Dec 2023

Collector Supreme sincerely has the best brick & mortar comic book inventory in central Ohio, hands down. They are the nicest people to deal with and are happy to answer your questions and help you find what you are looking for.

★★★★★ Sean, Mar 2025

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 56 on Google →

Where to find Collector Supreme

More comic shops nearby

Worlds Greatest Comics

5974 Westerville Rd

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
271Reviews
4Extras

4.7 miles away

The Laughing Ogre

4258 N High St

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
962Reviews
2Extras

6.9 miles away

Krazzy Comics

1010 N Hamilton Rd

Pull listsBack issuesSignings
4.8Rating
170Reviews
6Extras

9.4 miles away

Heroes and Games

400 N High St #157

Pull listsManga
4.5Rating
379Reviews
5Extras

12.1 miles away

Packrat Comics

3864 Lattimer St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
1,013Reviews
6Extras

12.2 miles away

Hobby Central

652 W Central Ave #28

4.7Rating
263Reviews
4Extras

12.6 miles away

All comic shops in Columbus, OH →

Comic shops in nearby cities

All comic shops in Ohio →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.