Home › Indiana › Indianapolis › Comic Carnival

Comic Carnival Comic book store in Indianapolis, IN

4.7 ★★★★★ 378 Google reviews

Buys comics Back issues

Comic Carnival is a comic book store at 7235 N Keystone Ave Ste e, Indianapolis, IN. It has a 4.7-star rating from 378 Google reviews. Customer reviews or the shop's own website show it offers back issues.

What it's known for

Each item is listed only when a customer review or the shop's own website mentions it.

  • “Endless rows of back issues, cleanly alphabetized and deep, dollar bins that are actually sorted, and a strong new release wall.”

    Google review · Mentioned 8 times in reviews

Sell your comics here?

Comic Carnival buys comics, per the shop's website.

Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now, whether they want a list first, and whether they pay cash or store credit.

Where to sell comics How to sell a collection

Also on the shelves

  • Toys & collectibles

    “After almost 30 years of being a customer, this is hands down the best place to find a home for your comic book, action figure & collectibles, and table top gaming needs!”

    Google review · Mentioned 5 times in reviews

From Google reviews

I have been a customer here since 2009. You can not find a better comic book store in my opinion. They know me by name and are always willing to order me things of they don't have them. They have games on the weekends and the staff and owners are the friendliest folks you'll meet.

★★★★★ Matthew, Sep 2016

I just wanted to say how much I absolutely love this comic book store! The selection is amazing, and the atmosphere is so welcoming. Plus, I love the guy that works there he’s very nice! It's definitely my favorite spot to find new comics and connect with fellow fans! Your buddies from Illinois

★★★★★ Wywy, Apr 2025

Oh look, a shop that actually sells blind bags instead of cutting them open then selling the comics in them at a 500 percent mark up like DOWNTOWN COMICS ($20 for a 1:10 blind bag variant? Get bent). This is a shop that is honest and not greedy to their customers. What a concept!

★★★★★ D, May 2025

A great selection of back issues and all the new books you need for your collection.

★★★★★ P.D., Jul 2021

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 378 on Google →

Where to find Comic Carnival

More comic shops nearby

Downtown Comics In Castleton

5767 E 86th St

Back issuesMangaFree Comic Book Day
4.4Rating
297Reviews
5Extras

3.2 miles away

Atomic Planet Comics

8906 E 96th St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
97Reviews
9Extras

6.4 miles away

Downtown Comics

11 E Market St

Back issuesManga
4.4Rating
321Reviews
5Extras

8.4 miles away

Hero House Comics

1112 Prospect St

Pull listsBack issuesManga
4.8Rating
173Reviews
5Extras

9.3 miles away

Prideland Comics & Collectibles LLC

5668 Crawfordsville Rd Ste D

Back issues
4.6Rating
74Reviews
2Extras

9.7 miles away

Jay Bryant: cosplay and props

21 S 2nd Ave

5Rating
35Reviews
2Extras

11.6 miles away

All comic shops in Indianapolis, IN →

Comic shops in nearby cities

All comic shops in Indiana →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.