Home › Indiana › Shelbyville

Comic book stores in Shelbyville, IN

We list 2 comic shops in Shelbyville, Indiana. Per their reviews or own websites, 1 carries back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.

Man Cave Comics and Collectibles

1310 Miller Ave

Back issues
4.7Rating
87Reviews
2Extras

LA Comics and Collectibles

10 E Broadway St

4.8Rating
48Reviews
2Extras

Compare Shelbyville comic shops

ShopRatingReviewsProven comic extras
Man Cave Comics and Collectibles1310 Miller Ave 4.7★ 87 Back issues
LA Comics and Collectibles10 E Broadway St 4.8★ 48 —

Extras show only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. A dash doesn't mean a shop lacks it.

What Shelbyville shoppers say

Man Cave Comics and Collectibles

Very charming shop. The owner is so nice and really knows his stuff! Really appreciated the vibes when we stopped in to visit on the hunt for some Magic cards. He only had a small supply of those, but kindly suggested another shop across town (LA Comics) in case they had any.

★★★★★ Sunny, Jan 2026

LA Comics and Collectibles

This is a shout-out to LA Comics and Collectibles. I went a few days ago to check out their GI JOE selection, thinking that it would be a few classified figures (which they had for all you modern fans out there), but I was blown away by their vintage GI JOE collection. They had some figures I thought I would never see.

★★★★★ Gunnar, Oct 2025

Excerpts from public Google reviews.

Comic shops near Shelbyville

Shop count and straight-line distance between city centers.

Shelbyville comic shop FAQ

How many comic book stores are in Shelbyville?
We list 2 comic shops in Shelbyville, out of 67 comic shops in 44 cities across Indiana.
Which Shelbyville comic shop ranks first?
By Google rating times review count, Man Cave Comics and Collectibles comes first, with 4.7★ from 87 reviews. For star rating alone (10+ reviews), LA Comics and Collectibles is highest at 4.8★ from 48 reviews.
Where can I sell comics in Shelbyville?
None of the Shelbyville shops we list say they buy comics in their reviews or on their websites. 3 shops elsewhere in Indiana do: see the Indiana buyers.
Are Shelbyville comic shops open on Sundays?
None of the 2 with hours on Google list Sunday hours. Hours change, so check before you go.
What other towns near Shelbyville have comic shops?
Greenfield (2 shops, 19 mi), Greenwood (1 shop, 21 mi) and Beech Grove (1 shop, 21 mi).

All comic shops in Indiana