Home › New York › Catskill › Sleepover Trading Co.

Sleepover Trading Co. Comic book store in Catskill, NY

5 ★★★★★ 41 Google reviews

Buys comics New shop

Sleepover Trading Co. is a comic book store at 373 Main St, Catskill, NY. It has a 5-star rating from 41 Google reviews.

Sell your comics here?

Sleepover Trading Co. buys comics, per the shop's website.

Call before you bring a collection in. Ask what they are buying right now, whether they want a list first, and whether they pay cash or store credit.

Where to sell comics How to sell a collection

Also on the shelves

  • Toys & collectibles

    “Everything I loved about my childhood can all be found here, whether it’s horror scores on vinyl, video rental, vintage comic books and magazines, or classic toys!”

    Google review · Mentioned 12 times in reviews

From Google reviews

This place is such a treasure trove. Amazing, nostalgic selection of movies and toys. They are very communicative, knowledgeable. and do super special interactive screenings monthly at the beautiful theater attached next door. A must-see for anyone in the catskills area!

★★★★★ Marillska, May 2026

Sleepover Trading Co. in Catskill feels like somebody cracked open a video store in 1995, a Saturday morning cartoon marathon, and a punk rock toy chest…then stitched it all together with love and pure nostalgia. This store has everything.

★★★★★ Bamf, May 2026

Can't say enough positive things about this store, and the incredible duo who run it. If you haunted the horror aisles of video rental stores as a child and teenager of the eighties and nineties and miss the magic, this place has an amazing stock if VHSes to rent as a member It's also filled with cool paperbacks,…

★★★★★ Kevin, Jun 2026

This store is an absolute treasure! So many memories unlocked instantly when I walked in. A great selection of vhs, toys and its they even have a movie rental program so you can re-live your friday night blockbuster ventures, which come on....were the best!

★★★★★ Alexandra, May 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 41 on Google →

Where to find Sleepover Trading Co.

More comic shops nearby

Pop's Universe

101-3 Main St

4.8Rating
24Reviews
1Extras

6.0 miles away

Worlds End Comics

319 Wall St Unit 1

Back issuesMangaFree Comic Book Day
4.9Rating
63Reviews
6Extras

21.2 miles away

POW! Card Games & Comics

175 Broadway

Back issuesFree Comic Book Day
4.8Rating
133Reviews
4Extras

22.3 miles away

Western MA Graphic Novels

152 Main St

5Rating
40Reviews
1Extras

25.8 miles away

Greenbush Out-of-Print Comics

Columbia Plaza, 501 Columbia Turnpike Ste G

Buys comics Back issues
4.9Rating
48Reviews
2Extras

27.9 miles away

Alterniverse

Shopping Plaza, 870 Violet Avenue Unit 7 Haviland

Back issuesSigningsFree Comic Book Day
4.8Rating
244Reviews
6Extras

31.0 miles away

All comic shops in Catskill, NY →

Comic shops in nearby cities

All comic shops in New York →

Independent listing, not affiliated with this shop. Details come from public business info, customer reviews and the shop's own website; confirm hours before you go.

Something out of date? Send a correction. Own this shop? Update your listing. It's free.