Home › Sell comics › New York › Rochester

Sell comics in Rochester, NY

3 comic shops in Rochester buy comics, out of 9 comic shops we list in the city. Each one is here because its own website or its customers' reviews say it buys, and the proof is shown with each shop. Ranked by Google rating × number of reviews.

Wonderland Comics

1620 Penfield Rd

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.8Rating
167Reviews
6Extras

I sold my comic book collection from childhood to Wayne last week.

★★★★★ Bill, Jun 2024

All Heroes Comics

4410 Lake Ave

Buys comics Back issues
4.7Rating
83Reviews
2Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Leone’s Collectibles

612 Stone Rd

Buys comics
4.2Rating
43Reviews
2Extras
Buys comics, per the shop's website

Getting a fair offer in Rochester

  1. Call the shops first. Ask whether they are buying right now, what they want, and when the buyer is in. For a large collection, set a time.
  2. Sort before you go. Put books in order by title and issue number, and keep older books and keys in their own stack. Bags and boards help, but a clean, sorted box matters more.
  3. Compare offers on your most valuable books. Wonderland Comics and All Heroes Comics may want different things, so the same box can get different offers.
  4. Ask for cash and store credit. Cash offers sit below resale value, because the shop has to sell the books again. Many shops offer more in credit.
  5. Expect little for bulk. Boxes of recent common issues are often bought as one lot for a low price, or not at all.

More on condition, keys and pricing: where to sell comic books · how to sell your comic collection.

6 other comic shops in Rochester don't show proof of buying yet. Some may still buy, so it can pay to ask. See every comic shop in Rochester →

Elsewhere in New York

27 comic shops in New York buy comics.