Home › Wisconsin › Madison

Comic book stores in Madison, WI

We list 3 comic shops in Madison, Wisconsin. Per their reviews or own websites, 1 buys comics, 2 have pull lists and all 3 carry back issues. Shops are ordered by Google rating times review count.

Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin

2831 E Washington Ave

Buys comics Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
337Reviews
8Extras

Westfield Comics - West

7475 Mineral Point Rd #22

Pull listsBack issues
4.7Rating
297Reviews
3Extras

Capital City Comics

1910 Monroe St

Back issues
4.2Rating
128Reviews
1Extras

The "Local fave" sticker marks the Madison shop with the highest Google rating times review count. It's a ranking of public numbers, not an endorsement.

Compare Madison comic shops

ShopRatingReviewsProven comic extras
Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin2831 E Washington Ave 4.7★ 337 Buys comics · Pull lists · Back issues · Manga · Vintage & keys · Signings · Free Comic Book Day · Indie & small press
Westfield Comics - West7475 Mineral Point Rd #22 4.7★ 297 Pull lists · Back issues
Capital City Comics1910 Monroe St 4.2★ 128 Back issues

Extras show only when a shop's reviews or its own website mention them; the proof is on each shop's page. A dash doesn't mean a shop lacks it.

What Madison shoppers say

Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin

Great comic shop, especially if you're looking for a wide variety of new releases. Tons of back issues, many separated by publisher, and lots of key issues displayed up on the walls throughout the store.

★★★★★ Nick, Jun 2023

Westfield Comics - West

Great shop for comics and graphic novels! Some toys and collectibles too. Everything is clean and well organized with separate sections for kids and manga as well. Definitely check out the sale bins for some good bargains.

★★★★★ Kidkyoto, Jul 2022

Capital City Comics

Great shop. Caution: Don't get the ire of Bruce. Tread lightly. I went to Capital City when young, 10 years old! Plenty of banter with Bruce. He is the comic-sage. I still love comics as an old dude aged 57! Alas, had a heated contact and unwelcome treatment by this store. Loved it but left it too.

★★★★★ Lars, Aug 2024

Excerpts from public Google reviews.

Selling comics in Madison?

Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin buys comics, per its reviews or its own website. 2 shops across Wisconsin do.

Where to sell comics in Wisconsin

Comic shops near Madison

Shop count and straight-line distance between city centers.

Madison comic shop FAQ

How many comic book stores are in Madison?
We list 3 comic shops in Madison, out of 34 comic shops in 26 cities across Wisconsin.
Which Madison comic shop ranks first?
By Google rating times review count, Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin comes first, with 4.7★ from 337 reviews.
Where can I sell comics in Madison?
Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin buys comics, per its reviews or its own website. Call ahead with a rough count of what you have.
Which Madison comic shops do pull lists?
2 shops: Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin and Westfield Comics - West. Their reviews or websites mention pull lists or subscriptions. A pull list holds each new issue of the series you follow. How pull lists work.
Are Madison comic shops open on Sundays?
2 of the 3 with hours on Google list Sunday hours: Graham Crackers Comics of Wisconsin and Westfield Comics - West. Hours change, so check before you go.
What other towns near Madison have comic shops?
Lake Mills (1 shop, 26 mi), Fort Atkinson (1 shop, 32 mi) and Oconomowoc (1 shop, 47 mi).

All comic shops in Wisconsin